Islamica Community

Sufi / Salafi?

You aren't logged in. Sign in below or register today!
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 01:44 PM
zzze's Avatar
zzze
Budding bedouin. Offline
 

Join Date: Nov 2003
Rating: 6 Votes / 4.33 Average
Posts: 9,023
zzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond repute
Question Sufi / Salafi?

Asslamau alaykum

I think we should leave the debates out of sufi circle/ tassawuf thread and bring them here insha Allah. No copy and paste buisness please

For those who lean the sufi/salafi way...what attracts you to it and why do you oppose the other? What really enhances ur belief that what you're following is the correct way?

jazakallahkhair
__________________
"Until you annihilate your selfish lower self of desires and lusts through strict and sincere mujahada [self disciplinary exercises], your heart will never become illuminated with the light of knowledge." - Imam Abu Hamid Al-Ghazli, Dear Beloved Son.

Help the GUANTANAMO BAY detainees
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 02:10 PM
bluey's Avatar
bluey
Sabrun Jameel Offline
 

Join Date: Dec 2004
Rating: 6 Votes / 4.33 Average
Posts: 5,597
bluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond reputebluey has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to bluey Send a message via MSN to bluey
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Assalam Alaykum,

I usually don't get into the Sufi/Salafi discussions on Islamica or other places because they simply are not worth it. Somehow or the other they always turn into a argument which equals fitna.

But just for the record, if you follow one thing, does not necessarily mean that you reject the other entirely. And Allah subhanna wa ta'ala knows best.
__________________
The Prophet Sallalahu alayhi wasallam said,

“There is no Muslim who forsakes a Muslim in a situation where his reputation and honor are violated except that Allah will forsake him in a situation where he would want His help, and there is no Muslim who helps a Muslim in a situation where his reputation and honor are being violated except that Allah will help him in a situation where he would want His help.”
[Abu Dawud]


Free Muslim Prisoners.
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 02:18 PM
Unity's Avatar
Unity
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 190
Unity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond reputeUnity has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Yea, i've noticed that ppl really get freaky and start e-yelling at others lol. Also, i dont think one has to choose one teaching of Islam. For example, I am a Muslim who has taken all the teachings that will help me get closer to Allah swt. Sooo...i guess i would simply call myself a Muslim and not a Sunni or a Sufi or a Shia or a Salafi. Hope you catch my drift
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 04:19 PM
Revert's Avatar
Revert
Resident Realist Offline
 

Join Date: May 2006
Rating: 5 Votes / 4.20 Average
Posts: 8,864
Revert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Revert
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Quote:
Originally Posted by bluey View Post
Assalam Alaykum,

I usually don't get into the Sufi/Salafi discussions on Islamica or other places because they simply are not worth it. Somehow or the other they always turn into a argument which equals fitna.

But just for the record, if you follow one thing, does not necessarily mean that you reject the other entirely. And Allah subhanna wa ta'ala knows best.
Exactly...great point Bluey..

I aim to practice tasawwuf in my quest to live a daily Jihad an-nafs, however that doesn't mean I fully reject what people consider the "salafi" way.
__________________
Ninjas can kill anyone they want! Ninjas cut off heads ALL the time and don't even think twice about it. These guys are so crazy and awesome that they flip out ALL the time. I heard that there was this ninja who was eating at a diner. And when some dude dropped a spoon the ninja killed the whole town. My friend Mark said that he saw a ninja totally uppercut some kid just because the kid opened a window.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 04:22 PM
sixpakistan's Avatar
sixpakistan
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: May 2004
Rating: 10 Votes / 3.00 Average
Posts: 12,757
sixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond reputesixpakistan has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to sixpakistan
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Salafiyyah is often represented as Islam stripped to its core components.

I feel that Salafiyyah is Islam stripped of its core components.

Hence, my leanings..
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 04:37 PM
sak01's Avatar
sak01
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Oct 2004
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 244
sak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond reputesak01 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Quote:
Originally Posted by sixpakistan View Post
Salafiyyah is often represented as Islam stripped to its core components.

I feel that Salafiyyah is Islam stripped of its core components.

Hence, my leanings..
Harsh but true.

Way to pick a fight though...
__________________
Ours is not to question why,
Ours is but to do and die.
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 05:03 PM
ShamilB's Avatar
ShamilB
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 185
ShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Quote:
Originally Posted by sixpakistan View Post
Salafiyyah is often represented as Islam stripped to its core components.

I feel that Salafiyyah is Islam stripped of its core components.

Hence, my leanings..
Salafiyya for me is all about following the Quran and Sunnah (if this is what you mean by "core components") and staying away from innovations. Hence why I find the "Salafi" way so appealing. If you think Salafiyya is devoid of self purification or dhikr, then you are clearly mistaken. To me Salafiyya is the sanctioned or halal way of purifying your souls and remembering Allah (swt) - the way the Prophet (saw), the Sahaba and the early generation of Muslims performed self-purification.

Last edited by ShamilB : 12-21-2007 at 05:27 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 05:36 PM
Jamroll's Avatar
Jamroll
ModRoll the Mergerator Offline
 

Join Date: Apr 2004
Rating: 16 Votes / 4.13 Average
Posts: 18,259
Jamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond reputeJamroll has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Salam,

I think there's good and beneficial things in both Sufi and Salafi circles. The problem arises from the reaction both groups get from each other, which can lead them to be come extreme in relation to one another.

Also, how we define these terms can lead to totally different interpretations of what it means to be a "sufi" or a "salafi".

Some "sufi" practices are deviant and even contain elements of shirk, and give real Sufis who adhere to the tenets of the Sharia a bad name. On the other hand, sufis in their real sense are those who practice tawassuf, concentrating on self-purification and developing a closer relationship with the Almighty.

Some "salafis" can seem to be rigid and wooden in their application, and give more importance to a unflinchingly literalist interpretation of everything. On the other hand, they strive hard to root out wrong, innovated ideas, and to return to the sources of Islam, the Qur'an and Sunnah.

However, personally I feel that there is a middle path between these two ends of the Islamic spectrum, which incorporates both tawassuf and self-purification, with the fundamental "rope of Allah", the Qur'an and Sunnah, and this is why I tend to find most favour with the idea of adhering to the madhab system, which has rich, deep and established roots in both these areas.
__________________
The time will never be ‘just right’.
Start where you stand, work with whatever tools you may have at your command,
and better tools will be found as you go along.
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 05:41 PM
Revert's Avatar
Revert
Resident Realist Offline
 

Join Date: May 2006
Rating: 5 Votes / 4.20 Average
Posts: 8,864
Revert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond reputeRevert has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Revert
Default Re: Sufi / Salafi?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jamroll View Post
Salam,

I think there's good and beneficial things in both Sufi and Salafi circles. The problem arises from the reaction both groups get from each other, which can lead them to be come extreme in relation to one another.

Also, how we define these terms can lead to totally different interpretations of what it means to be a "sufi" or a "salafi".

Some "sufi" practices are deviant and even contain elements of shirk, and give real Sufis who adhere to the tenets of the Sharia a bad name. On the other hand, sufis in their real sense are those who practice tawassuf, concentrating on self-purification and developing a closer relationship with the Almighty.

Some "salafis" can seem to be rigid and wooden in their application, and give more importance to a unflinchingly literalist interpretation of everything. On the other hand, they strive hard to root out wrong, innovated ideas, and to return to the sources of Islam, the Qur'an and Sunnah.

However, personally I feel that there is a middle path between these two ends of the Islamic spectrum, which incorporates both tawassuf and self-purification, with the fundamental "rope of Allah", the Qur'an and Sunnah, and this is why I tend to find most favour with the idea of adhering to the madhab system, which has rich, deep and established roots in both these areas.
Nice post...very well put..
__________________
Ninjas can kill anyone they want! Ninjas cut off heads ALL the time and don't even think twice about it. These guys are so crazy and awesome that they flip out ALL the time. I heard that there was this ninja who was eating at a diner. And when some dude dropped a spoon the ninja killed the whole town. My friend Mark said that he saw a ninja totally uppercut some kid just because the kid opened a window.
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 06:16 PM
zzze's Avatar
zzze
Budding bedouin. Offline
 

Join Date: Nov 2003
Rating: 6 Votes / 4.33 Average
Posts: 9,023
zzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond repute
Default sufiliyya :p

assalamu alaykum

jazakallahkhair to everyone who replied
Quote:
Originally Posted by sixpakistan View Post
Salafiyyah is often represented as Islam stripped to its core components.

I feel that Salafiyyah is Islam stripped of its core components.

Hence, my leanings..
wow, ok...what about those who don't define ''salafiyyah'' in the same way that you do...those who incorporate dhikr etc into their lives...what makes that different from your ''leaning''?

Quote:
Originally Posted by ShamilB View Post
Salafiyya for me is all about following the Quran and Sunnah (if this is what you mean by "core components") and staying away from innovations. Hence why I find the "Salafi" way so appealing. If you think Salafiyya is devoid of self purification or dhikr, then you are clearly mistaken. To me Salafiyya is the sanctioned or halal way of purifying your souls and remembering Allah (swt) - the way the Prophet (saw), the Sahaba and the early generation of Muslims performed self-purification.
I guess my concern is that most of the mosques that I've been to that label themselves as ''salafi'' are all about what to avoid, with ''Do not deviat!!!'' being the main khutbah...but what you define salafiyya to be is very different from what I've come across alhamdulilah.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Jamroll View Post
Salam,

I think there's good and beneficial things in both Sufi and Salafi circles. The problem arises from the reaction both groups get from each other, which can lead them to be come extreme in relation to one another.

Also, how we define these terms can lead to totally different interpretations of what it means to be a "sufi" or a "salafi".

Some "sufi" practices are deviant and even contain elements of shirk, and give real Sufis who adhere to the tenets of the Sharia a bad name. On the other hand, sufis in their real sense are those who practice tawassuf, concentrating on self-purification and developing a closer relationship with the Almighty.

Some "salafis" can seem to be rigid and wooden in their application, and give more importance to a unflinchingly literalist interpretation of everything. On the other hand, they strive hard to root out wrong, innovated ideas, and to return to the sources of Islam, the Qur'an and Sunnah.

However, personally I feel that there is a middle path between these two ends of the Islamic spectrum, which incorporates both tawassuf and self-purification, with the fundamental "rope of Allah", the Qur'an and Sunnah, and this is why I tend to find most favour with the idea of adhering to the madhab system, which has rich, deep and established roots in both these areas.
ah, the middle way! the radical middle way (habib ali/umar etc)

Now the moderate paths in both ways seem to be the same, I'm no longer able to tell the difference between the two. However, I'm yet to meet a ''salafi'' who actually incorporates self purifcation into their daily lives, whereas I've met so many people who wouldn't class themselves as sufis (as they deem themselves unworthy) strongly stick to the Qur'an and Sunnah AND seek to purify themselves, so what would they be called, sufi or salafi?

I think that sounds like the right balance.
__________________
"Until you annihilate your selfish lower self of desires and lusts through strict and sincere mujahada [self disciplinary exercises], your heart will never become illuminated with the light of knowledge." - Imam Abu Hamid Al-Ghazli, Dear Beloved Son.

Help the GUANTANAMO BAY detainees
Reply With Quote
  #11 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 06:36 PM
ShamilB's Avatar
ShamilB
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 185
ShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: sufiliyya :p

Quote:
Originally Posted by zzze View Post
I guess my concern is that most of the mosques that I've been to that label themselves as ''salafi'' are all about what to avoid, with ''Do not deviat!!!'' being the main khutbah...but what you define salafiyya to be is very different from what I've come across alhamdulilah.
Self-purification can be achieved in many ways - praying sunnah or nafl prayers, reciting the Quran, praying qiyaam-ul layl, fasting on mondays and thursdays and many other acts of sunnah - these are all means of self purification.
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 06:39 PM
zzze's Avatar
zzze
Budding bedouin. Offline
 

Join Date: Nov 2003
Rating: 6 Votes / 4.33 Average
Posts: 9,023
zzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: sufiliyya :p

assalamu alaykum

true, tho interesting how the acts of ibaada you mentioned are all external
__________________
"Until you annihilate your selfish lower self of desires and lusts through strict and sincere mujahada [self disciplinary exercises], your heart will never become illuminated with the light of knowledge." - Imam Abu Hamid Al-Ghazli, Dear Beloved Son.

Help the GUANTANAMO BAY detainees
Reply With Quote
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 06:55 PM
ShamilB's Avatar
ShamilB
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 185
ShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond reputeShamilB has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: sufiliyya :p

Quote:
Originally Posted by zzze View Post
assalamu alaykum

true, tho interesting how the acts of ibaada you mentioned are all external
The concept of dhikr is not alien to the Salafis - this is a common misconception that many people have. The prophet (saw) himself did dhikr after Salat, during Ramadan, during the night. What is uncommon is the idea of a communal dhikr session where you are told to recite Allah's name a specified number of times, and if you do you get rewarded with a certain blessing. There are many many other examples but you get the drift.
Reply With Quote
  #14 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 06:58 PM
zzze's Avatar
zzze
Budding bedouin. Offline
 

Join Date: Nov 2003
Rating: 6 Votes / 4.33 Average
Posts: 9,023
zzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond reputezzze has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: sufiliyya :p

asslamau alaykum

uncommon in what, with who? The recitation of Allah swt's names isn't just for communal practice.
__________________
"Until you annihilate your selfish lower self of desires and lusts through strict and sincere mujahada [self disciplinary exercises], your heart will never become illuminated with the light of knowledge." - Imam Abu Hamid Al-Ghazli, Dear Beloved Son.

Help the GUANTANAMO BAY detainees
Reply With Quote
  #15 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007, 07:38 PM
Abdul_Karim's Avatar
Abdul_Karim
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Nov 2005
Rating: Not Rated
Posts: 448
Abdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond reputeAbdul_Karim has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: sufiliyya :p

Quote:
Originally Posted by zzze View Post
assalamu alaykum

true, tho interesting how the acts of ibaada you mentioned are all external
All the things that Sufis do (sama, hadhrah, khalwah, the various awrad recited by mureeds) are external acts as well, with the exception of the Naqshabandi silent dhikr. I think it's funny how the Sufis act like they're all about the inner workings of the heart, when they are as focused on external ritual as the Salafis.
__________________
“There is not on the face of the earth—after the Book of Allah—a book which is more sahih than the book of Malik.” - Imam ash-Shafi'i
Reply With Quote