[Shahnawaz]

Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo

Very good question. I don't know.

Actually no, not a good response at all. Such knowledge has always been around and a fatawa of takfir against those who commit such acts have too.

And what the hell kind of remark is that? Why now? Are you dumb? Its better late than never! Jaani seems to simpley dislike the fact this guy has had a Takfir done upon him, one which has plenty support. This is not to say the other actors don't have it, its just a specific one is yet to be made.

[jaani]

Originally Posted by Shahnawaz

Actually no, not a good response at all. Such knowledge has always been around and a fatawa of takfir against those who commit such acts have too.

And what the hell kind of remark is that? Why now? Are you dumb? Its better late than never! Jaani seems to simpley dislike the fact this guy has had a Takfir done upon him, one which has plenty support. This is not to say the other actors don't have it, its just a specific one is yet to be made.

whoa, dont attack me dude.......i was just curious because of all the media attention suddenly upon him because of him participating in hindu religion, which is wrong, but a lot of other muslim actors have done that and no one did much about it(at least i havent heard it)...

i'm not being ignorant and i'm not taking any sides....obviously, it is better late than never

~j

[WarriorAndWiseman]

...can we get a fatwa on his movies and get them banned? All of them? They're all hindu movies now so it should be easy enough.

[shsh]

Originally Posted by WarriorAndWiseman

...can we get a fatwa on his movies and get them banned? All of them? They're all hindu movies now so it should be easy enough.

i wouldnt mind..hes so gay...

[jinnzaman]

Originally Posted by jaani

ok, but why now? I mean, this isn't something new, they have been acting up for a very long time, so why have the clerics decided to give them a fatwa now?

~j

The Hanafi madhab is built upon what is known as the "case method." The case method involves deducing rules of law from actual real life cases. As such, unless a particular legal question is posed, an answer is typically not given so as to refrain from delving into purely hypothetical or theoretical matters. In this case, someone asked a specific question concerning Salman Khan's actions and a scholar elucidated the matter by giving a fatwa. Its not the duty of the 'Ulema to police the people; but if questions are asked to them, they give fatwas.

[WarriorAndWiseman]

Originally Posted by shsh

i wouldnt mind..hes so gay...

Thank you thank you thank you.

I swear if I ever meet him on the street I'll kill him!!

[ChotooMotoo]

Bolywood movies suck anyway, and actors are usually very fake superficial people. I don't know why people get so obsessed with them anyway.

[jaani]

Originally Posted by jinnzaman

The Hanafi madhab is built upon what is known as the "case method." The case method involves deducing rules of law from actual real life cases. As such, unless a particular legal question is posed, an answer is typically not given so as to refrain from delving into purely hypothetical or theoretical matters. In this case, someone asked a specific question concerning Salman Khan's actions and a scholar elucidated the matter by giving a fatwa. Its not the duty of the 'Ulema to police the people; but if questions are asked to them, they give fatwas.

why do you make sense all the time? thanks!

~j

[jinnzaman]

Originally Posted by jaani

why do you make sense all the time? thanks!

~j

Remember me in your duas.

[jaani]

Originally Posted by jinnzaman

Remember me in your duas.

uh....ok

~j

[shsh]

Originally Posted by jaani

why do you make sense all the time? thanks!

~j

that is so true...

[GOTFIVEONIT]

Originally Posted by Aryan_

Go commit sati.

awww you bash your own fellow muslims then you cant take what you dish out?

[GOTFIVEONIT]

that's true jaani its not just salman, its the other khan's too, and the other Muslim actors as well who act like a bunch of jahil hindus by taking part in thier religious ceremonies, and that is completely wrong too. in fact the video link provided in the first post shows shah rukh khan teaching his kids 'bismillah' - in front of hindu idols.

[Kona_Silat]

Why are Muslims against pluralism? He is raising his children to respect both faiths and to promote the idea of unity between Hindus and Muslims in a country where they are at each others throats. I think it is a beautiful gesture in a world full of hatred. It is like raising a child to be biracial. He is giving them the best of both worlds.

Originally Posted by Aryan_

Hinduism is polytheism. Just because they also believe in one commanding overall god doesn't mean it isn't polytheistic.

Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo

Christians believe they worship only one God. That doesn't make any of them Muslim or make any of their beliefs Islamically correct.

Says the Muslims who nothing of the Hindu religion. Can we find a Hindu on this board that can speak for his/her faith?

[ChotooMotoo]

Originally Posted by Kona_Silat

Why are Muslims against pluralism? He is raising his children to respect both faiths and to promote the idea of unity between Hindus and Muslims in a country where they are at each others throats. I think it is a beautiful gesture in a world full of hatred. It is like raising a child to be biracial. He is giving them the best of both worlds.

There is a difference between teaching someone to be tolerant of other faiths, and teaching them to practice another faith. If you are Muslim, you must believe and practice Islam as the superior religion. If you are Hindu, you must believe and practice Hinduism as the superior religion. You can teach tolerance and cultural understanding, that doesn't mean you have to participiate in shirk. Hinduism and Islam don't mix.