[sixpakistan]

Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo

It's about limits.

So what? It still makes no sense. It's like saying "Ooh, a guy wearing less than knee length shorts! I know, let's ban guys who eat filet-o-fishes!" It's just dumb and nonsensical.

Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo

And yes, I've heard people get upset about girls wearing jeans, ANY jeans, since for some reason there is no way to wear jeans modestly.

Then that's a separate issue. If you want to criticize people who think jeans can't be worn modestly, that can't follow from/necessarily be associated with criticizing people who say wearing a less than full length skirt is immodest, because from an Islamic perspective, wearing less than a full length skirt is immodest without question.

Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo

There was zero logic/sense behind discussing peoples clothing at an MSA board meeting either. What kind of MSA do they have that they don't have more important issues to discuss than how people dress?

That's not really relevant to whether your point was valid.. "there was 0 logic/sense behind blah blah, so let me address blah blah with even less logic/sense"

Also, as an aside regarding whether it's important or not that people (guys & girls both, gotfiveonit-esque gender advocacy aside) are modestly dressed, remember that according to the Prophet (SAW), the innate character of our deen is modesty.. if part of the purpose of the MSA is to create an Islamic environment, it certainly is important.