Quote:
Originally Posted by AliFazel
Which System is republic in nature with Ulemah as its guardians besides the Islamic republic of Iran?
If you ask the Bahai and Ahmedia – They will say it isn’t Islamic.
To believe in Sahadah according to Sunni and Shia view is to accept Muhammad(SAW) as khatem-un-Nabieen.
This the Bahai and Ahmedia ppl reject.
|
Actually, Bahais don't claim to be Muslim, and Ahmadis also recite the Shahadah.
Sunnis and Shi`as do not see eye to eye on the Shahadah or the issue of Khatm an-nabuwat. The Sunnis say that the seal of Prophets means that there can be no person after the Prophet (s) who has the rank of Prophethood or Messengership, whereas the Shi`as believe that they can have Imams who are higher in rank.
So we don't see eye to eye on this, dear colleague.
This is not an attack on your belief...only showing the difference between Sunnis and Shi`as in regards to the Shahadah and the Khatm an-nabuwat.
Quote:
|
IRAN IS THE ONLY THING CLOSE TO ISLAMIC SYSTEM – and the only pure Islamic system, we shall have after this, will inshallah be THE GOVERNMENT OF MAHDI (A.J.)
|
If I were a Shi`a, then I too would love Iran, no doubt. There can be no doubt that Iran has been extremely beneficial to Shi`as. They have spent hundreds of millions of dollars pumping out Shi`a dawah materials, funding Shi`a movements, and fighting to create a Shi`a crescent.
But we are not Shi`as. We are Sunnis. And for Sunnis, Iran has been nothing but bad news. Yes, the Sunnis of Iran did help with the revolution, but what happened after Khomeini came to power? He jailed the Sunni scholars, banned their organizations, and persecuted even the Sufis...Please visit the Ahle Sunnat Iran website insha-Allah.
So conclusion is: Iran is great for Shi`as, not so great for Sunnis.