View Single Post
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 12-16-2007, 12:57 PM
Kona_Silat's Avatar
Kona_Silat
Banned Offline
 

Join Date: Mar 2004
Rating: 10 Votes / 1.60 Average
Posts: 7,361
Kona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond reputeKona_Silat has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via MSN to Kona_Silat Send a message via Yahoo to Kona_Silat
Default Re: Debate I had about scholars

Quote:
Originally Posted by m_ali_qazi View Post
scholars are inheritors of the prophet peace be upon him and even the prophet was questioned.

There are specific times when the scholar cannot be questioned, but I doubt that applies to average people.
But what makes a person a "scholar" as opposed to an average person because that was what the conflict was about? Shinta Nuriya is just a Muslim feminist activist, yet because she studied at a madrassah does that also make her an Islamic scholar.
Reply With Quote