View Single Post
  #50 (permalink)  
Old 07-24-2008, 05:46 PM
jinnzaman's Avatar
jinnzaman
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Jul 2003
Rating: 11 Votes / 3.64 Average
Posts: 19,123
jinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond reputejinnzaman has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to jinnzaman
Default Re: Ethnic Cleansing in America

Quote:
Originally Posted by ChotooMotoo View Post
Local law enforcement doesn't equal federal government, neither do "vigilante groups." You're going to have to prove that ethnic cleansing had a real federal mandate for all these groups. The only one I'm aware of is Native Americans.

As for Mexicans in the Great Depression, they were kicked out, they were systematically killed. So far as I'm aware, ethnic cleansing does require violence, or it's just relocation.

If you're going to argue that even non-violent relocation, or non-government mandated persecution of minorities is the same as ethnic cleansing, than the Muslim world has a HUGE problem. Be careful with your definitions.
Firstly, a governmental action is still a governmental action, regardless if it is local, state, or federal.

Secondly, the federal government did participate in ethnic cleansing on multiple occasions (such as using the military to forcibly relocate the Indians).

Thirdly, its ethnic cleansing because not only were they kicked out but their property and land were seized after they left.

Fourthly, who says that ethnic cleansing has to be violent?
__________________
I've quit Islamica. I will now be posting here:
Shield of Islam Forums
Reply With Quote