View Single Post
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 06-02-2008, 10:05 AM
zeyneddine's Avatar
zeyneddine Offline
Islamican Troll
 

Join Date: Mar 2008
Age: 23
Posts: 1,317
zeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond reputezeyneddine has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Taxi drivers taking a person anywhere--even to sin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaysh View Post
Question: I am a taxicab driver who owns my own cab. According to the law in the city where I work, I cannot discriminate between passengers and cannot refuse to take them places. Also, I used to work in another city where there were no such laws on the books. However, I worked for a taxicab company that prohibited drivers from refusing customers. Is my profession lawful? Am I allowed to take passengers to nightclubs and bars?

Answered by Sheikh Muhammad Muhammad Sâlim `Abd al-Wadűd

Taking people to places where lawful and unlawful activities are both possible – like a restaurant, a hotel, or the general marketplace – is perfectly lawful. You are not obliged to ask them what they are going to eat and drink at the restaurant.

This is a matter about which there is general agreement.

Scholars differ regarding taxicab drivers taking passengers to places where they will certainly be carrying out predominantly unlawful activities. Such places include bars, nightclubs, and known brothels. Many scholars deem this prohibited, since it is helping people in sin and iniquity.

Allah says: “Help ye one another in righteousness and piety but do not help one another in sin and rancor. Fear Allah: for Allah is strict in punishment.” [Sűrah al-Mâ’idah: 2]

However, even in these cases, if taxicab drivers are prohibited from refusing passengers by law or by company regulations, or due to the negative feelings against Muslims that refusing passengers might engender in society, then it will be permissible to take all passengers wherever they want to go.

This is because a taxicab driver’s work is basically lawful in and of itself. Indeed, the driver is providing people with an essential service. If either the law or circumstances prohibit drivers from discriminating against passengers, this does not mean that Muslims should be barred from an essentially lawful and useful profession.

And Allah knows best.

Islamtoday.Com - Taxicab drivers taking customers anywhere
This is an interesting issue. Can the same be said of the Curry and Beer shops in the UK? How about BYOB Curry shops? The former I would say def. no, but latter would seem okay based on the above fatwa. Am I incorrect?
__________________
Originally Posted by ZakiDambass2008
Zey you are a real troll you must not have gf or bf for that matter and either you have ben really burned or you have no feelings or compassion for your fellow man/woman it is people like you that is why there is so much fightiting going on in this world. Zey i dont hate anyone but i hate you i think yo are repulsive and disgusting and you hurt people for no apprent reason.
Reply With Quote