Quote:
Originally Posted by Haramoobobi
I don't think she was commenting on the person but rather the answer as to " what kind of people live in this world" it could mean the questioner but perhaps she also meant some 'people of knowledge' and the fallibilities of humans--which makes it valid too. I really think you're nit-picking esp when the reputation of anyone isn't at hand and no one in general is mentioned. There's a lot of "mights" in the world. I know a man who had been molested by an imam--you didn't include that in your "might". And for the record, knowledge doesn't make anyone innately good. It's their words, deeds, actions--in which in this case we were judging on words. Thanks 
|
i'm not nitpicking; i'd like to think certain people on this forum wouldnt take a reminder such as the one i posted personally. i think jelly would be pretty mature in that sense. i know i always appreciate being corrected if i'm at fault. anyway sincerely no offense to jelly if i sounded harsh
and what does an imam molesting someone have to do with somebody as you said we dont know much about? i dont get it. the person may very well be pious (we should assume the best) and in that case what was said can be seen as disrespectful.
as for someone being good or not, let's not judge that far. i like to think people just dont randomly decide to 'waste' their lives studying deen and invest so much time in something that doesn't even 'pay' well - time they could've spent on other things.
i'm not trying to pick a fight or argue out of boredom, honestly. it just bothers me when someone who is knowledgeable is spoken of in that manner and i tend to take it personally.