View Single Post
  #64 (permalink)  
Old 04-28-2008, 11:29 PM
Hanbali's Avatar
Hanbali
Senior Member Offline
 

Join Date: Mar 2008
Rating: 7 Votes / 3.14 Average
Posts: 1,007
Hanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond reputeHanbali has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Giving the Headscarf a Makeover in Germany

Trent, stop twisting my words and rewording them so I say something other than what I did. It's annoying.

You said:

Quote:
WEARING A PIECE OF FABRIC ON YOUR HEAD DOES NOT DICTATE HYPOCRISY!!!!
Did I say differently?

Then you quoted me here:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hanbali
I never said that all hijabis are better than all non-hijabis.
And here:

Quote:
I think they should be advised and cautioned.Remember: a hoey hijabi is better than a hoey non-hijabi. Something is better than nothing.

Do you see how these two statements do not contradict each other?

A Hayaful hijabi is superior to an equally Hayaful non-hijabi.
A hoey hijabi is inferior to a hayaful non-hijabi.
A hoey hijabi is superior to an equally hoey non-hijabi.

That is my position.

Quote:
When sixpak agreed with you that it is a fallacy to think that its hypocritical for a hijabi to wear tight clothes, he validated my claim that it is a fallacy to assume that its better for someone to wear the scarf when they are obviously not following the religion, and that wearing the scarf even when they dont believe, as you advocated, is STUPID.
Six Pak never said any such thing. He already posted telling you that he never once disagreed with me. It is up to you to continue defending your third grave reading comprehension.
Reply With Quote