Quote:
Originally Posted by AliFazel
it was said that Prophet (SAW) is alive in his grave
|
How many times have we gone over this!?
And by the way, you grave worshippers do not do tawassul like the Sufis do. At least the Sufis just ask the occupant of the grave to ask Allah [swt] for them. (I still think that is wrong but at least they are directing their request to Allah [swt] in a convoluted way.) So they say "O Prophet , make du`a for me...."
On the other hand, you grave worshippers directly ask the occupant of the grave for things. You say "Ya Ali Madad" (O Ali, YOU help me). You ask him directly for things. Same way with the Prophet [s].
So the Sufis will say "O Prophet, pray to God to give us rain..."
Whereas you will say "O Prophet, give us rain!" Shirk akbar.
Quote:
|
– so If I go to the grave of Prophet (SAW) and talk to him – seek his help – why do the Saudi people beat us and drive us away?
|
Because it is shirk.